Background
Proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) are the most widely prescribed medications in the country. They suppress acid in the stomach, raising the stomach pH from about 2 to 5-6. Medicines in this class include Prilosec, Nexium, Prevacid, and Protonix. They represent a multibillion dollar industry each year. Prilosec was the first in the class, but another class of acid suppressing medications preceded proton pump inhibitors. This class of medications, called the H2 blockers, includes Pepcid, Zantac, and Tagamet. The proton pump inhibitors are more effective in suppressing acid in the stomach and have surpassed the H2 blockers in popularity. A practice of starting them in hospitalized patients has been become a trend without significant evidence of benefit. The belief is that during periods of stress, such as a hospitalization, people are at more risk for stress ulcers. This may be true in intensive care settings, but probably not for less complicated hospitalizations. Many patients are discharged home, continuing these medications indefinitely after the hospitalization.
Nature and physiology
The acid environment of the stomach serves many purposes.
Acid acts as a natural defense to invading bacteria and other pathogens from the outside world. It was long ago noticed that people with a condition called achlorhydria, a disorder where the stomach acid is low, were at higher risk for contracting tuberculosis. There is evidence that chronic acid suppression with PPIs can make people at higher risk for certain infections such as pneumonia and certain gastrointestinal infections like Clostridium difficile, which causes infectious colitis.
The acid environment in the stomach aides in digestion.
The first part of digestion of proteins is facilitated by acid. Many important nutritional elements, such as iron, magnesium and calcium, are more readily absorbed when the stomach has its natural acid levels. Higher fracture rates are seen in people on chronic acid suppression and are thought to be related to impaired absorption of calcium. Chronic acid suppression with proton pump inhibitors may interfere with the absorption of vitamin B12.
Rebound acid.
Another problem with chronic acid suppression is that once you have been on them, it may be hard to get off of them. The body adjusts to the chronic use of PPIs by increasing gastrin levels. Gastrin is a hormone that is secreted to assist in digestion. One of gastrin’s functions is to keep the acid levels in the stomach appropriate. It has been shown that gastrin levels climb after long term use of PPIs. Once a person who has been on a PPI long term tries to stop, gastrin levels can be sufficiently high to cause a rebound, or hyper-secretion of acid, making it difficult to stop.
Effect on medications.
Many medications are designed to break down in the high acid environment of the stomach. When the stomach acid is absent, they may not digest as well. Enteric coated aspirin came to the market to help people who have a sensitive stomach. Ironically, it is designed to not break down in the acid environment of the stomach. It has a coating that is resistant to acid and breaks down more readily in the intestines where the environment is more basic (less acidic). The acid suppressing medications, like PPIs, can cause enteric coated aspirin to behave just like ordinary aspirin in the stomach, by-passing the intended effect of the coating, and quite possibly, causing stomach complaints because of the PPI. Some PPIs interfere with the metabolism of clopidogrel (Plavix).
Solutions/options
I have dealt with people who chronically take PPIs. I know how hard it is to stop these medications. For some people this is a quality of life issue. If you are awaken every night by a boring or burning in your chest and a pill prevents it, the medications can be life altering. I have solutions for people who are trying to improve their lives with acid suppression.
Try to taper acid suppression.
Taper the dose. Use the medication only when necessary and find out when it is “necessary.” This can be done by keeping a log of symptoms or food diary. By doing an assessment of your personal experience with foods and situations, you can begin to target these symptoms pre-emptively with medication. Reducing the amount of medication taken will help to reduce potential side effects and save money.
Diversify your armamentarium.
Try a varied approach to your acid suppression. Use H2 blockers, PPIs, and antacids. It may be that your really bad episodes related to stomach acid respond to a PPI, but others may respond to an H2 blocker or an antacid like Maalox or Tums. By diversifying your treatment, you will avoid chronic therapy directed at one site in the body. Although this has not been studied, it could “unbind” certain physiologic processes in the body, allowing them to return to normal during the varied treatment approach. This, in theory, could allow elevated gastrin levels to drop if they were altered by PPI therapy.
Consider other modifications.
Avoidance of certain foods that you find cause problems is important. These foods aren’t the same for everyone so document your triggers. Classic food triggers include chocolate, caffeine, alcohol, fatty foods, and peppermint. If acid reflux is the issue, losing weight, even small amounts, helps. Keeping the head of the bed elevated helps. Wearing less restrictive clothing, such as tight belts or pants, may help reduce abdominal pressure. Many people don’t realize that snoring at night may increase acid reflux. When your upper airway is partially blocked at night, as it is with snoring or sleep apnea, your chest wall works harder to get air into the lungs. This creates a low pressure in the chest cavity and allows for acid from the stomach to seep into the lower pressure area of the esophagus. Treating the apnea or snoring can help reduce acid reflux. Some medications can predispose you to acid reflux but the list is too long to include here so discuss it with your doctor.
When Acid Suppressing medications should not be stopped.
I am not suggesting that you should stop your acid suppressing medications. There are many conditions where this would be a bad idea. If you have conditions such as Peptic Ulcer disease, esophageal varices, erosive gastritis or erosive esophagitis, Barrett’s esophagus, or Zollinger-Ellison Syndrome, you definitely are benefitting from suppressing acid. I am suggesting that outside of these conditions, you should have a discussion with your doctor about the best way to use the lowest effective dose of medication for your symptoms. Acid suppressing medications like PPIs have been on the market less than 25 years. The long term effects of these medications are probably still not completely known.